Wash your potatoes thoroughly. Poke with a fork and season with oil, salt and pepper.
Wrap each in aluminum foil. Slice an ‘X’ on the top of each and bake in an 300°F oven for 1 hour. Broil for 5 additional minutes.
Once cooked through, squeeze the jackets with a pair of tongs in order to open the ‘X’s at the top of the potatoes. Top with your choice of toppings and enjoy while warm.